For newer products, what makes a thread feel real instead of over-written?

[admin]

Newer product threads can be hard to read because some of them feel overly polished right away.

When a thread is about a newer compound or a less familiar listing, what makes it feel more believable to you?

Do you look for smaller practical details, slower back-and-forth replies, clearer uncertainty, or something else entirely?

Would be good to hear what helps newer threads sound like normal discussion instead of marketing copy.